In the span of just two weeks, the percentage of respondents in AAII‘s investor sentiment survey reporting as bullish has risen from the middle of the past few years’ range of 33.07% to 45.6% (and from 41.83% last week), the highest reading since early October 2018. Back then, bullish sentiment peaked out just slightly higher at 45.66%, before turning lower as stocks sharply sold off.
Bearish sentiment is another story. In spite of the strong bullish reading, bearish sentiment was actually lower in the final weeks of 2019 and the first week of this year. Now at 24.77%, bearish sentiment is low but still within a normal range of one standard deviation of the past year’s average of 30.04%.
Last week, we noted that AAII‘s weekly reading on neutral sentiment fell below its historical average for the first time in 22 weeks. Although the week-over-week decline was fairly small at just around one percentage point this week, that slide has continued as neutral sentiment has fallen further to 29.63%. This is the first time that the sentiment reading has fallen below 30 since the first week of last year.
Neutral sentiment dropping so low indicates that investors have become increasingly polarized; mostly placing themselves in the bullish camp. In fact, in the past two weeks, both sentiment readings have reached fairly elevated levels relative to the past year. Bullish sentiment is now more than 1 standard deviation above the past year’s average of 33.7%, while neutral sentiment is 1 standard deviation below its average of 36.26% over the past year. This was the first time this has occurred, while bearish sentiment remained within its normal range since early 2018. As shown below, of the 20 prior times in the history of the survey that bullish sentiment has been similarly elevated (over 1 standard deviation above the past year’s average) while neutral sentiment is simultaneously extended below its average without having done so in the prior six months has resulted in near-term underperformance compared to other periods. The S&P 500 has averaged declines in the next week and month following such readings. Fortunately, longer-term returns have been stronger and more consistently positive.
Editor’s Note: The summary bullets for this article were chosen by Seeking Alpha editors.